Oilers: Should Pickard Start More?

viatrucks.com Team Editor

You need 3 min read

·

Post on Feb 09, 2025

34 visitor like this post

Share

Oilers: Should Pickard Start More?

The Edmonton Oilers' goaltending situation has been a source of much debate this season. While Stuart Skinner has solidified himself as a reliable starter, the performance of backup Laurent Brossoit has been inconsistent, leaving many fans and analysts questioning whether the team should give more starts to veteran netminder, Mike Pickard. This article delves into the arguments for and against increasing Pickard's ice time.

Analyzing Pickard's Performance

Mike Pickard, a seasoned NHL goaltender, has displayed flashes of brilliance when given the opportunity. He possesses a calm demeanor under pressure and showcases strong technical skills. His save percentage in limited appearances has been surprisingly competitive, suggesting he might be a more reliable option than Brossoit on certain nights. However, the sample size is relatively small, making it difficult to draw definitive conclusions.

Key Strengths:

• Experience: Pickard's years of experience in the league provide a valuable asset, particularly during crucial games or playoff scenarios. His ability to read plays and anticipate shots is a testament to his time in the net.
• Consistency (in limited opportunities): While his appearances have been infrequent, his performance in those games has been relatively consistent, showcasing a level of reliability not always seen from other Oilers goaltenders this season.
• Calm demeanor under pressure: His steady presence in net can positively influence the team's overall defensive performance.

Key Weaknesses:

• Limited playing time: The lack of consistent starts makes it challenging to accurately assess his long-term performance and potential. More games are needed to determine his true capabilities and consistency.
• Competition for ice time: With Skinner establishing himself as the clear number one and Brossoit still in the mix, it's a tough battle for playing time. Opportunities to showcase his skills are limited.
• Potential for rust: Limited game action can lead to rust and inconsistency, impacting his performance when he's finally given a chance.

The Case for More Starts

The Oilers' need for consistent goaltending is undeniable. If Brossoit continues to struggle, giving Pickard more starts makes logical sense. A change in goaltending can significantly impact the team's momentum and overall performance, especially during critical periods of the season. A fresh, reliable option could bring much-needed stability to the Oilers' defense. Additionally, increasing Pickard's playing time allows the team to more accurately gauge his capabilities and determine his long-term role within the organization.

The Case Against More Starts

Conversely, rushing Pickard into a significant role could be detrimental to the team's success. Skinner’s strong performance shouldn't be overlooked. Disrupting his rhythm by frequently switching goalies might negatively impact team morale and create inconsistencies in the defensive strategy. The coaching staff also needs to consider the potential risks of inserting a goaltender who lacks regular game action. The risk of rust and inconsistency might outweigh the potential benefits of a change.

The Verdict: A Strategic Approach

Ultimately, the decision of whether to increase Pickard's starts rests on a careful evaluation of various factors. The Oilers' coaching staff needs to continuously monitor the performance of all three goaltenders, consider their long-term plans, and adapt their strategy as the season progresses. A strategic approach, balancing the need for consistent performance with the development of potential, is crucial for the team's success. Closely analyzing game statistics, individual player performance, and the overall team dynamics will be vital in making the right decision moving forward.

While a definitive answer remains elusive without more data, the ongoing discussion surrounding Pickard's role is a testament to the depth and complexity of the Oilers' goaltending situation, and the ever-evolving challenge of finding the optimal balance in team composition. The coming games will undoubtedly provide further insight into the optimal path forward.